A Fan-Favorite Reese’s Collab Is Back and Fans Are Begging For It to Stay

Reese’s is the GOAT when it comes to peanut butter cups. There’s just something about that proprietary Reese’s flavor that no competitor can quite replicate. (Though Aldi fans swear its less expensive copycat is superior.)

So, if you’re going to roll out a peanut butter-chocolate treat, you might as well go straight to the source and get the good stuff. And Crumbl, the beloved cookie chain with those signature pink boxes all over social media, did just that with a brand-new Reese’s sweet.

But this time it’s not a cookie (or a hand pie)—it’s something so much better.

Crumbl’s New Peanut Butter Cup Brownie Ft. Reese’s

No hate on Reese’s Pieces, these protein bars, or even the Reese’s chocolate bread that took the internet by storm, but Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups are unequivocally the best way to enjoy the iconic flavor combo. And chains know it. This summer, Rita’s Italian Ice is serving up “Concretes” with the classic candy; Chili’s recently used the cups to top its first new dessert in 10 years. And now Crumbl is back with a new Reese’s creation: the Peanut Butter Cup Brownie featuring Reese’s.

This isn’t Crumbl’s first time featuring Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups. Last year, it topped a cookie with the peanut butter cups, as well as offered a Reese’s Pieces-studded cookie for a limited time. A Crumbl spokesperson told Allrecipes, “This is the first time we have used Reese’s in a dessert,” meaning a brownie, cake, or cheesecake.

The gooey brownie is definitely reminiscent of last year’s Nothing Bundt Cakes and Reese’s collab with a dense, chewy base, but the new Crumbl creation is topped with a velvety peanut butter mousse, chocolate drizzle, and chopped Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.

One Redditor who tried the treat before the official release said the brownie “felt extremely rich and decadent, more so than Crumbl’s other cookies.”

The last time Crumbl offered a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup treat, fans begged the chain to keep it forever. One Instagram user said, “This was easily [the] best cookie made in all of human existence. Bring back the Reese!!!” Hopefully, the new brownie will satisfy fans, who are still commenting on that Instagram post from nearly a year ago.

The Peanut Butter Cup Brownie ft. Reese’s is available as a Crumbl Large Dessert, or as a part of a Mini Desserts pack. It will run you about $6, but it’s certainly large enough to share.

Sadly, this decked-out brownie is only available for a limited time. The flavor is part of a Father’s Day-themed release this week, so if you want to try the new Reese’s treat, you have until June 14 to snag it.